Despite my love of Indian people and Indian food, I have never been very interested in visiting India. Unfortunately, Macdonald didn’t convince me to change my mind. Sure, I loved reading about her growing appreciation for the chaos and contradictions of India, but I’m content to let that be her story and not mine.
The book is interesting, but a little awkward. Some chapters detail her personal life (losing her hair, nearly dying of double pneumonia, meeting Bollywood superstars), while others chronicle her pursuit of religious experiences. I liked both, but the book as a whole didn’t feel cohesive.
Since India is the birthplace of a huge number of religions, it makes sense that Macdonald, previously an atheist, would take advantage of her new life to explore the realm of the spiritual. I enjoyed learning about Sikhism, Zoroastrianism, Hinduism, Islam, etc alongside her. But, like many spiritual explorers, she tends to highlight the pros and ignore the cons. In the end, she wants to take a little something from each religion, and she never stops to discuss the fact that this belittles many of the religions that claim this picking and choosing is impossible. It felt like she didn’t want to offend anyone, which, while understandable, doesn’t exactly make for persuasive writing.
I’m always down for a book that explores the topics of travel and religion, and I’m glad I spent time reading Holy Cow. But I don’t think I’ll be rereading anytime soon. Continue reading